Reagent matrix
Reagent against taxon, for the records published so far. A negative result is recorded rather than left blank, because a negative result is evidence: it tells you what the specimen is not.
MELZ Melzer's reagentWeight 3.00
- Preparation
- 0.5 g iodine + 1.5 g potassium iodide + 20 g chloral hydrate in 20 ml distilled water
- What it tests
- Spore wall and spore ornamentation, examined at 1000x in a water mount
- Verdict vocabulary
- Amyloid — blue-black to grey-blue · Dextrinoid — reddish-brown to rusty · Inamyloid — pale yellow to unchanged, the colour of the reagent itself
Chloral hydrate softens the spore wall so the iodine can reach the inner layers; without it (Lugol's) only the outer wall reacts and amyloid spores read as a much weaker blue. Read the result within 2 minutes — chloral hydrate slowly bleaches the preparation.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays yellow-brown; no blue-black development. |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | inamyloid | Spores stay pale; a faint grey wash on some spores is not a blue-black amyloid reaction and should not be read as one. |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | inamyloid | Spore wall remains olive-yellow; no blue or red-brown development. |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays pale yellow; no blue or red-brown development over 5 minutes. |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | dextrinoid | Spore wall turns a deep reddish-brown to rusty within 2 minutes — a strong pseudoamyloid reaction that looks amyloid at low magnification and must be read at 1000x. |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays pale; no blue-black development at any magnification. |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays dark yellow-brown; no blue-black amyloid development. |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | inamyloid | The spore wall does not turn blue-black, but the coarse warts are strongly outlined and the ornamentation is far easier to count than in water. |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | inamyloid | No blue-black reaction; the warts outline sharply and are easier to count than in a water mount. |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays pinkish; no blue-black development, and the facets do not darken. |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | inamyloid | Spore wall does not turn blue-black, but the ornamentation is thrown into sharp relief and the smooth plage becomes obvious. |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | inamyloid | Spore wall and the ascus tips stay pale yellow; no blue-black amyloid reaction in either. |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays yellow-brown and the germ pore does not darken; no blue-black development. |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | dextrinoid | Spore wall turns reddish-brown within 2 minutes; the reaction is uniform and easy to read at 400x. |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | dextrinoid | Spore wall and the inner wall layers turn reddish-brown to rusty within 2 minutes — the classic dextrinoid reading. |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays pale yellow; no blue-black or rusty development. |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays ochre-brown; no blue, no red-brown intensification. |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays pale; no blue-black development. |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays olive; no blue-black or rusty development. |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | inamyloid | Spore wall and spines do not turn blue-black; the ornamentation is however outlined more sharply than in water. |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | inamyloid | Spore wall stays pale yellow; no blue-black development at any concentration. |
KOH5 Potassium hydroxide 5%Weight 2.00
- Preparation
- 5 g KOH pellets in 95 ml distilled water
- What it tests
- Cap cuticle, flesh in the cap centre, and the stem base
- Verdict vocabulary
- Chrome yellow — immediately, then fading to brown · Olive to greenish-grey · Reddish-brown to vinaceous · No change
The reaction is a surface phenomenon: wipe the cap cuticle with the drop rather than flooding a cut section. Chrome yellow on a yellowing agaric is the single most useful bedside test in this bench, because the colour is strong enough to read in daylight and survives the specimen drying out.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | positive | Cap cuticle flashes chrome yellow within seconds, then fades through orange to brown over about a minute — the reaction is fast enough to be visible while you are still holding the pipette. |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | negative | Cap cuticle lightens to yellow-brown or, on the pale form, stays almost unchanged; no chrome yellow flash. |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | variable | Cap cuticle turns orange-brown to red-brown within 30 s on most collections; the flesh stays unchanged, which is the reading that matters. |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | negative | Cap cuticle dulls to greyish-brown but develops no yellow, green or vinaceous tone. |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | positive | Cap scales turn orange-brown; the pale ground between them stays unchanged, producing a strongly mottled result. |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | negative | Cap shows no reaction whatever; the white pigment is stable to alkali, unlike that of some pale Clitocybe species which yellow. |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | negative | Cap surface unchanged; the reddish-brown tips of the scales are stable to alkali. |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | negative | Cap cuticle darkens to a deeper red-brown without turning yellow or green. |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | positive | Cap cuticle turns a deep blood-red to vinaceous within 30 s, then fades to brown — a reaction several Cortinarius share and which is not diagnostic on its own. |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | negative | Cap surface darkens slightly to grey-brown; no yellow, green or red development. |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | negative | Cap cuticle darkens to a dull brown; no chrome yellow, no red. |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | negative | Head surface darkens slightly and the crust softens; no yellow, green or red development. |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | negative | Cap surface darkens to olive-brown; the yellow and green pigments are stable to alkali. |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | negative | Cap squamules darken slightly to a deeper brown; no yellow or green development. |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | positive | Cap squamules turn orange-brown to greenish-brown; the pale ground tissue between them shows no reaction. |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | negative | Cap shows no reaction whatever; the buff pigment is stable to alkali, which is not true of the pale Clitocybe look-alikes. |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | positive | Cap cuticle turns a deep red-brown to mahogany within 30 s, markedly darker than the untreated surface. |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | negative | Cap and gills show no reaction whatever; the white pigment is stable to alkali. |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | positive | Cap cuticle turns orange-brown; the red pore surface darkens to a deeper blood-red without turning yellow. |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | negative | The rind darkens to a deeper brown and softens; the gleba does not change colour. |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | negative | Cap cuticle darkens to olive-brown, but the yellow pigments are otherwise stable and produce no red flash. |
FESO4 Iron(II) sulfate 10%Weight 3.00
- Preparation
- 10 g FeSO4·7H2O in 90 ml distilled water, used fresh
- What it tests
- Cap flesh, and the surface of the stem in the upper third
- Verdict vocabulary
- Olive-green — slow, developing over 30 s · Salmon-pink to flesh-pink · Grey-blue to slate · No change
Salmon-pink flesh salt is the one reaction in this bench that separates otherwise identical pale russulas from the Tricholoma group. Use a fresh solution: an oxidised, rust-coloured stock reads as a false positive on everything.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | negative | Flesh unchanged or very faintly grey after 60 s; no salmon-pink. |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | negative | Flesh shows no reaction within 60 s; occasional faint grey-green over the cuticle is within range. |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | slow-positive | Flesh develops a grey-green to olive wash over 60-90 s; a fast salmon-pink here indicates a different genus entirely. |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | negative | Flesh shows no colour change after 60 s; a faint grey wash on the cuticle is within normal variation. |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | negative | Flesh shows no reaction within 60 s or a very faint grey-olive wash. |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s. |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | negative | Flesh shows no reaction within 60 s. |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s; a faint grey wash on the cortina zone is within range. |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s. |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s; no salmon-pink. |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | negative | Flesh and cuticle unchanged after 60 s. |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | negative | Stem flesh and head tissue unchanged after 90 s. |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s. |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s. |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s; a slow grey-green wash occasionally appears on the stem context. |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 90 s at 10% concentration. |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | positive | Flesh develops an olive-green to grey-green wash over 30-60 s, especially in the stem context. |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | negative | Flesh unchanged after 60 s. |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | positive | Flesh develops a grey-green to olive wash within 30 s, faster and stronger in the stem base than in the cap. |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | negative | Rind and young gleba unchanged after 90 s. |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | negative | Cap flesh unchanged after 60 s. A salmon-pink reaction here would place the specimen in the russulas instead. |
ANIS Anisaldehyde (with sulfuric acid)Weight 2.00
- Preparation
- 0.5 ml anisaldehyde + 1 ml concentrated sulfuric acid in 8.5 ml 96% ethanol
- What it tests
- Cap cuticle and cap flesh, on a fresh or a well-dried specimen
- Verdict vocabulary
- Grey-violet to black — the strong reaction · Grey-violet only at the disc · Negative — no change, or a pale yellow that is the reagent itself
Anisaldehyde is the reagent that separates the tricholomas, the lepiotas and the entolomas from the pale species they are confused with, and it is the one bench reagent whose result improves on a dried specimen: a cap dried at 40 C gives a cleaner reading than a rain-soaked fresh one. Read at five minutes and again at thirty; the weak reactions drift in over half an hour and the strong ones start to blacken the slide.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | not tested | — |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | negative | No change on the cap cuticle or on fresh flesh; the drop stays the colour of the reagent itself. |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | not tested | — |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | not tested | — |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | negative | No change on cap or flesh; the white of the fruit body is unaffected at thirty minutes. |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | positive | Grey-violet spreading from the cuticle into the flesh at the disc, reading near-black at five minutes. |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | not tested | — |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | not tested | — |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | positive | Grey-violet on the cap cuticle within two minutes, deepening towards black over the disc at thirty minutes. |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | not tested | — |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | negative | No change on the reviving cap; the buff tone reads the same wet and dry. |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | negative | No change on the cap; the brown pigment is not displaced by the reagent at any concentration. |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | negative | No change on the white cap or on the translucent flesh. |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | not tested | — |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | not tested | — |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | negative | Nothing beyond a faint grey cast on the cap after five minutes; the flesh never darkens, which is what separates it from the strongly reacting tricholomas. |
NH4OH Ammonium hydroxide 10%Weight 2.00
- Preparation
- 10 ml concentrated NH4OH in 90 ml distilled water
- What it tests
- Cap cuticle; also useful on the ring surface of Amanita
- Verdict vocabulary
- Yellow to apricot · Green to blue-green · Purplish then fading · No change
Ammonia and KOH overlap on many taxa; run them on opposite sides of the same cap so a shared result does not masquerade as two independent confirmations. Ammonia is markedly better than KOH at pulling colour out of a dry cap.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | positive | Cap and flesh turn yellow immediately, matching the KOH result; the two should be run on opposite sides of the same cap so that the duplicate is not mistaken for independent confirmation. |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | not tested | — |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | negative | Cap cuticle darkens slightly or shows no reaction; no yellow or green flash. |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | not tested | — |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | negative | Cap surface darkens slightly; no yellow, green or purple development. |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | not tested | — |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | not tested | — |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | not tested | — |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | not tested | — |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | not tested | — |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | positive | Cap surface and flesh turn a brownish-red immediately, then fade over several minutes. |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | not tested | — |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | positive | Flesh and pore surface turn greenish-blue immediately, especially at the stem base. |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | not tested | — |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | not tested | — |
COTTON Cotton blue in lactophenolWeight 2.00
- Preparation
- 0.05 g methyl blue + 20 g phenol + 20 ml lactic acid + 20 ml glycerol per 100 ml
- What it tests
- Spore ornamentation, cystidia walls, and clamped septa
- Verdict vocabulary
- Cyanophilic — wall or warts stain deep blue · Weakly cyanophilic — pale blue outline only · Acyanophilic — remains unstained
The stain fills the space between warts, so the pattern reads as a negative image. Photograph within 10 minutes; the phenol fraction clears the preparation and the contrast falls off after that.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | not tested | — |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained; the thin wall shows a clear, evenly thick outline against the blue background. |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained against a blue background; the outline reads as a clear halo. |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | not tested | — |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained and appear as clear outlines. |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | cyanophilic | Spore wall stains deep blue, the central germ pore remaining as an unstained window. |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | cyanophilic | Warts stain blue against a paler wall, giving a strongly patterned outline. |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | cyanophilic | Warts stain blue against a paler wall. |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained and the angular outline reads clearly against the blue background. |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | cyanophilic | The warty ornamentation stains blue and the plage stays clear, so the spore reads as an ornamented oval with a bare notch. |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained; the two oil drops show as clear refractile bodies against the blue background. |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | not tested | — |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | cyanophilic | The thick wall stains blue and the germ pore remains a clear unstained window. |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | cyanophilic | The thick spore wall stains blue, leaving the germ pore as a clear unstained patch at one end. |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained, appearing as clear outlines. |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | not tested | — |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | not tested | — |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | not tested | — |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained, but the spines take up a pale blue edge that makes them easier to count. |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | acyanophilic | Spores remain unstained; the thin smooth wall shows as a clear outline. |
SULFOVAN Sulfovanillin (SV)Weight 1.00
- Preparation
- 1 g vanillin in 10 ml concentrated sulfuric acid, diluted 1:1 with distilled water
- What it tests
- Cystidia contents in the gill trama and on the gill edge
- Verdict vocabulary
- Blue-black · Violet then grey · Negative — unchanged or yellowish
Applied to a squash mount, not to a whole gill. Mix on a clean slide; a trace of iron from a reused needle turns the whole drop black and voids the test.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | not tested | — |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | not tested | — |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | not tested | — |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | not tested | — |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | not tested | — |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | not tested | — |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | not tested | — |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | not tested | — |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | not tested | — |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | not tested | — |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | not tested | — |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | not tested | — |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | not tested | — |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | not tested | — |
GUAIAC Guaiac tinctureWeight 1.00
- Preparation
- 1 g gum guaiac dissolved in 10 ml 70% ethanol, kept dark and used within a month
- What it tests
- Fresh context tissue and the cut surface of the stem
- Verdict vocabulary
- Blue — rapid, within 30 s · Blue after 2 min · Negative
A positive guaiac reaction indicates an extracellular laccase, which places the specimen among the white-rot wood decayers. It is a metabolic marker, not a toxicity marker: a strong blue says nothing about whether the fruit body is safe to handle or to eat.
| Record | Tier | Verdict | Reaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agaricus xanthodermus | T1 | not tested | — |
| Amanita phalloides | T3 | not tested | — |
| Boletus edulis | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cantharellus cibarius | T0 | not tested | — |
| Chlorophyllum molybdites | T1 | not tested | — |
| Clitocybe dealbata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Coprinus comatus | T0 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius orellanus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Cortinarius rubellus | T3 | not tested | — |
| Entoloma sinuatum | T2 | not tested | — |
| Galerina marginata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Gyromitra esculenta | T3 | not tested | — |
| Hypholoma fasciculare | T1 | positive | Fresh context turns blue within 30 s — a strong positive, consistent with a white-rot wood decayer rather than a litter saprotroph. |
| Lepiota brunneoincarnata | T3 | not tested | — |
| Macrolepiota procera | T0 | not tested | — |
| Marasmius oreades | T0 | not tested | — |
| Paxillus involutus | T2 | not tested | — |
| Pleurocybella porrigens | T2 | positive | Fresh context turns blue within 60 s, consistent with a white-rot wood decayer. |
| Rubroboletus satanas | T1 | not tested | — |
| Scleroderma citrinum | T1 | not tested | — |
| Tricholoma equestre | T2 | not tested | — |
Legend
- acyanophilic8
- cyanophilic6
- dextrinoid3
- inamyloid18
- negative40
- positive15
- slow-positive1
- variable1